Skip to content

Synectic

Christmas tree in an empty office space

Holiday fraud risk: when controls slip over the break

Most fraud doesn’t need a clever scheme; it just needs an opening. The Christmas holiday period creates several openings at once: key people are on leave; others are covering roles they don’t usually do; suppliers want to be paid before close-down; and everyone is tired and keen to get out the door.

The controls your organisation relies on were designed for a normal week, with the right people in the right seats. Over the break, these conditions can quietly fall away.

Controls don’t disappear. The people who run them do.

Over the break, your policies stay the same on paper. What changes is who is operating them, and whether anyone is checking. Three patterns are worth watching.

Approving and paying fall on one person.

With the usual approver away, the person processing payments also approves them “just this once”. Segregation of duties still exists in the policy, but it isn’t happening.

Access expands and nobody pulls it back.

Colleagues or temporary staff covering a role are given system access to keep things moving. Unless someone owns removing it, that access can linger.

Urgency overrides process.

The rush to get things paid before the break is exactly the sort of pressure a fraudster will exploit. A late request to change a supplier’s bank details is more likely to slip through when everyone is rushing, or the person who would normally question it is on leave.

What the data tells us

These patterns aren’t hypothetical. The latest global data is clear about where fraud starts. The Association of Certified Fraud Examiners’ (ACFE) Occupational Fraud 2026: A Report to the Nations found that the most common internal control weaknesses were a lack of internal controls, management override of existing controls, and a lack of management review. These three weaknesses accounted for 70% of cases in the study.

Conversely, five controls were found to be the most effective in reducing losses from fraud: management review, proactive data monitoring and analysis, a code of conduct, surprise audits, and job rotation and mandatory leave.

The break can also bring fraud to light

One of the behavioural red flags the ACFE tracks is a refusal to take leave.

Someone who never takes a break, and never lets anyone else near their work, may simply be dedicated. Or they may be protecting something. When another person steps into the role, irregularities have a way of surfacing. It helps explain why job rotation and mandatory leave rank among the most effective controls. Yet they were in place in only 27% of cases in the ACFE study.

You can use the break as a live test of your controls. Ask people covering roles to flag anything that doesn’t look right (and make it easy for them to do so). Even where nothing is wrong, fresh eyes often spot gaps that could be exploited, or steps that could simply work better.

Seven governance questions to ask before close-down

Whoever oversees your organisation, whether that’s the owner, CEO, Board or Audit Committee, should expect clear answers to these questions before the break.

1. Who approves what, and who is their backup?

Confirm delegations and spending limits for the period (in writing), including who steps in if the delegate can’t be reached.

2. Is segregation of duties still intact?

Where it can’t be, what is the compensating control?

A second approver from senior leadership or the Board, or dual authorisation in your banking platform, keeps the check in place.

3. What temporary access is being granted and when does it end?

Set the end date when access is granted, and have someone confirm when it has been removed.

4. How are changes to supplier bank details verified?

Your standard policy should require a call-back to a number already on file or from an independent source such as the supplier’s official website, never one supplied in the request. Reinforce the policy with anyone performing these roles over the break.

5. What gets reviewed when people return?

Payments made, new suppliers, changes to supplier details and manual journals over the period should be reviewed by someone who wasn’t involved.

6. How will you spot what doesn’t look right?

If your systems allow it, run an exception report. For example, look for payments outside normal patterns, or payments approved by the person who processed them. Keep the timing or scope of the check unannounced. A review people can’t predict is a stronger deterrent.

7. Do people know what to look out for and how to raise a concern?

Tip-offs are the most common way fraud is found: 43% of cases in the ACFE data, nearly three times the next most common method. That only works if your team, including temporary staff, know the warning signs and how to report them. Before the break, circulate a short reminder of your code of conduct, along with details of how to report concerns.

Keep it simple

The break is a predictable pressure point that comes around every year. That makes it one of the easiest fraud risks to plan for. A short conversation before close-down about who approves, who checks and what gets reviewed on return costs very little. An investigation in February costs a great deal more – in money, time and trust.

Take the next step

Synectic’s internal audit and risk specialists can help you test whether your controls work in practice, not just on paper.

Contact our team and we’ll work through the seven questions with you before the break.

Picture of Claire Connelly

Claire Connelly

Principal - Assurance and Advisory Services at Synectic. Claire has almost 20 years’ experience across the private and public sectors and is a volunteer board member. She is passionate about business performance and cares deeply about strong and empathetic leadership.
Share the Post:

Other News & Events

Gifting to family this Christmas
News

Gifting to family this Christmas

Thinking of giving family money? Whether helping a child into their first home, or giving a significant gift, here’s what to check first: your retirement plans, Centrelink gifting limits, and why a gift or loan should be in writing.

Read more
News

ATO NFP Self-Review Return

The ATO’s NFP self-review return is due 31 October 2026. If your not-for-profit hasn’t checked its governing documents against the new clause requirements, this is a priority. Here’s what you need to know.

Read more

Join Our Newsletter

Disclaimer


About Synectic Wealth Synectic

Wealth Pty Ltd is the financial services division of the Synectic group of accountants, auditors, business advisers, self-managed super fund (SMSF) specialists, and financial advisers. We are based in Devonport, Launceston and Hobart and provide services across Tasmania.

 

Synectic Wealth Pty Ltd ABN 24 615 317 194

Corporate Authorised Representative No. 1250871 of Alliance Wealth Pty Ltd AFSL 449221 | ABN 93 161 647 007 | Financial Services Guide

Information on this webpage has been prepared on a general advice basis only. We have not considered your objectives, personal or financial circumstances. You should consider the appropriateness of the advice for your circumstances before making any decision.

Where the advice relates to the acquisition, or possible acquisition, of a particular financial product, you should obtain and consider the relevant Product Disclosure Statement and seek the assistance of an authorised financial adviser before making any decision regarding any products or strategies mentioned in this communication.

Self-managed superannuation funds are not cost competitive for lower balance accounts and are not appropriate for all investors due to the time, cost and responsibility involved in managing an SMSF. For these reasons, it is imperative that you seek advice from your financial adviser before making any investment decisions.

This will close in 0 seconds